ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Cannot pass null argument when using type hinting

The following code:

class Type {

}

function foo(Type $t) {

}

foo(null);

failed at run time:

PHP Fatal error: Argument 1 passed to foo() must not be null

Why is it not allowed to pass null just like other languages?


S
Sean the Bean

PHP 7.1 or newer (released 2nd December 2016)

You can explicitly declare a variable to be null with this syntax

function foo(?Type $t) {
}

this will result in

$this->foo(new Type()); // ok
$this->foo(null); // ok
$this->foo(); // error

So, if you want an optional argument you can follow the convention Type $t = null whereas if you need to make an argument accept both null and its type, you can follow above example.

You can read more here.

PHP 7.0 or older

You have to add a default value like

function foo(Type $t = null) {

}

That way, you can pass it a null value.

This is documented in the section in the manual about Type Declarations:

The declaration can be made to accept NULL values if the default value of the parameter is set to NULL.


So why isn't null the null object?
Most languages allow null to have any type. In this scenario.
In my opinion this is a poor language construct. 1. In other languages null has the ability to be of any type thus making null a valid argument in this case. 2: Php is using a default value for an argument to specify that null is allowable, this is obscure and it makes a mandatory parameter impossible even if the developer wants to force a null to be explicitly passed.
I agree with @Henry, in addition it looks weird to have required params after what looks like an optional param.
I agree with @Henry only on 2. Regarding 1 the fact that you can't pass null to function foo(Type $t) is a VERY good thing; see Null References: The Billion Dollar Mistake
T
TheOperator

Starting from PHP 7.1, nullable types are available, as both function return types and parameters. The type ?T can have values of the specified Type T, or null.

So, your function could look like this:

function foo(?Type $t)
{

}

As soon as you can work with PHP 7.1, this notation should be preferred over function foo(Type $t = null), because it still forces the caller to explicitly specify an argument for the parameter $t.


S
SeanWM

Try:

function foo(Type $t = null) {

}

Check out PHP function arguments.


The problem I have with this is that it changes the definition of the function. Now the parameter is optional - which isn't really what the author intended (although, if he is passing it null, it is implicitly optional).
F
Fabian Schmengler

As other answers already mentioned, this is only possible if you specify null as the default value.

But the cleanest type-safe object oriented solution would be a NullObject:

interface FooInterface
{
    function bar();
}
class Foo implements FooInterface
{
    public function bar()
    {
        return 'i am an object';
    }
}
class NullFoo implements FooInterface
{
    public function bar()
    {
        return 'i am null (but you still can use my interface)';
    }
}

Usage:

function bar_my_foo(FooInterface $foo)
{
    if ($foo instanceof NullFoo) {
        // special handling of null values may go here
    }
    echo $foo->bar();
}

bar_my_foo(new NullFoo);

This approach is often impractical, because instead of 1 class, you now need 3. Also, it forces the writer of NullFoo to override abstract methods, even though they have no meaning (by definition of null).
In my experience the NullObject pattern can be practical, if you work in general in a very strict, classical OO way. In the answer, imo the NullObject pattern is a bit abused, as it is especially meant to avoid if (something is null) checks, as the NullObject is meant to cover all behavior of a non-existing value and any outside collaborator should not need to be interested in whether an object is non-existing (null) or not.
S
Syscall

As of PHP 8.0 (released November 26, 2020), you can also use the nullable union types.

This means that you are allowed to pass either Type or null as the parameter value:

function foo(Type|null $param) {
    var_dump($param);
}

foo(new Type()); // ok : object(Type)#1
foo(null);       // ok : NULL

Read more about union types.


c
chispitaos

In my case, the problem was the native "trim" function, that not accepts null. Let's suppose that you've this code:

if (trim($tables) != '') 
{
 //code 
} 

PHP8, also throws this error; so you've to create a custom "trim" function, like this one, to make it work.

  public function custom_trim(?string $value)
  {
    return trim($value ?? '') ;
  } 

I really hate this change from 7.4 to 8