I have two apps that use Integrated Security. One assigns Integrated Security = true
in the connection string, and the other sets Integrated Security = SSPI
.
What is the difference between SSPI
and true
in the context of Integrated Security?
Integrated Security = True
or SSPI
are not same. Integrated Security=true;
doesn't work in all SQL providers, it throws an exception when used with the OleDb
provider. So basically Integrated Security=SSPI;
is preferred since works with both SQLClient
& OleDB
provider. I have added an answer for better clarification.
According to Microsoft they are the same thing.
When false, User ID and Password are specified in the connection. When true, the current Windows account credentials are used for authentication. Recognized values are true, false, yes, no, and sspi (strongly recommended), which is equivalent to true.
Integrated Security=true;
doesn't work in all SQL providers, it throws an exception when used with the OleDb
provider.
So basically Integrated Security=SSPI;
is preferred since works with both SQLClient
& OleDB
provider.
Here's the full set of syntaxes according to MSDN - Connection String Syntax (ADO.NET)
https://i.stack.imgur.com/spIRt.jpg
Using Windows Authentication
To connect to the database server is recommended to use Windows Authentication, commonly known as integrated security. To specify the Windows authentication, you can use any of the following two key-value pairs with the data provider. NET Framework for SQL Server:
Integrated Security = true;
Integrated Security = SSPI;
However, only the second works with the data provider .NET Framework OleDb. If you set Integrated Security = true
for ConnectionString an exception is thrown.
To specify the Windows authentication in the data provider. NET Framework for ODBC, you should use the following key-value pair.
Trusted_Connection = yes;
Source: MSDN: Working with Connection Strings
Many questions get answers if we use .Net Reflector
to see the actual code of SqlConnection
:) true
and sspi
are the same:
internal class DbConnectionOptions
...
internal bool ConvertValueToIntegratedSecurityInternal(string stringValue)
{
if ((CompareInsensitiveInvariant(stringValue, "sspi") || CompareInsensitiveInvariant(stringValue, "true")) || CompareInsensitiveInvariant(stringValue, "yes"))
{
return true;
}
}
...
EDIT 20.02.2018 Now in .Net Core we can see its open source on github! Search for ConvertValueToIntegratedSecurityInternal method:
ConvertValueToIntegratedSecurityInternal
. That property is used only when provider is SqlClient
so in SqlClient
, SSPI
&true
are same but not when client is OleDb
or OracleClient
. I have clarified that in stackoverflow.com/a/23637478/704008 with msdn reference
Integrated Security = False : User ID and Password are specified in the connection. Integrated Security = true : the current Windows account credentials are used for authentication.
Integrated Security = SSPI : this is equivalant to true.
We can avoid the username and password attributes from the connection string and use the Integrated Security
Let me start with Integrated Security = false
false
User ID and Password are specified in the connection string.
true
Windows account credentials are used for authentication.
Recognized values are true
, false
, yes
, no
, and SSPI
.
If User ID
and Password
are specified and Integrated Security is set to true
, then User ID
and Password
will be ignored and Integrated Security will be used
Note that connection strings are specific to what and how you are connecting to data. These are connecting to the same database but the first is using .NET Framework Data Provider for SQL Server. Integrated Security=True will not work for OleDb.
Data Source=.;Initial Catalog=aspnetdb;Integrated Security=True
Provider=SQLOLEDB;Data Source=.;Integrated Security=SSPI;Initial Catalog=aspnetdb
When in doubt use the Visual Studio Server Explorer Data Connections.
What is sspi?
Connection Strings Syntax
True is only valid if you're using the .NET SqlClient library. It isn't valid when using OLEDB. Where SSPI is bvaid in both either you are using .net SqlClient library or OLEDB.
In my point of view,
If you dont use Integrated security=SSPI,then you need to hardcode the username and password in the connection string which means "relatively insecure" why because, all the employees have the access even ex-employee could use the information maliciously.
Success story sharing