ChatGPT解决这个技术问题 Extra ChatGPT

Correct way to initialize empty slice

To declare an empty slice, with a non-fixed size, is it better to do:

mySlice1 := make([]int, 0)

or:

mySlice2 := []int{}

Just wondering which one is the correct way.

You say "non-fixed size", but slices are never have a fixed size. Unless you mean with zero capacity. Note, if you have an idea/guess/hint of what capacity you might need then using the three argument version is good. E.g. to build a slice of map keys: keys := make([]int, 0, len(m)); for k, v := range m { keys := append(keys,k) }
Possible duplicate of Declare slice or make slice?

A
ANisus

The two alternative you gave are semantically identical, but using make([]int, 0) will result in an internal call to runtime.makeslice (Go 1.16).

You also have the option to leave it with a nil value:

var myslice []int

As written in the Golang.org blog:

a nil slice is functionally equivalent to a zero-length slice, even though it points to nothing. It has length zero and can be appended to, with allocation.

A nil slice will however json.Marshal() into "null" whereas an empty slice will marshal into "[]", as pointed out by @farwayer.

None of the above options will cause any allocation, as pointed out by @ArmanOrdookhani.


Also mention on wiki github.com/golang/go/wiki/…
Be care: json.Marshal() will return null for var myslice []int and [] for initialized slice myslice := []int{}
Also be careful: reflect.DeepEqual makes a distinction between nil slices and non-nil slices: a := []int{}, var b []int, reflect.DeepEqual(a, b) // returns false
Why you think it would do an allocation? Cap is zero so nothing is allocated. All pointers to zero length things point to the same location in memory: play.golang.org/p/MPOKKl_sYvw
@ArmanOrdookhani You are correct. I tried it out, and I also found out that I was wrong with my assumption on identical assembly instructions. Fixed!
i
icza

They are equivalent. See this code:

mySlice1 := make([]int, 0)
mySlice2 := []int{}
fmt.Println("mySlice1", cap(mySlice1))
fmt.Println("mySlice2", cap(mySlice2))

Output:

mySlice1 0
mySlice2 0

Both slices have 0 capacity which implies both slices have 0 length (cannot be greater than the capacity) which implies both slices have no elements. This means the 2 slices are identical in every aspect.

See similar questions:

What is the point of having nil slice and empty slice in golang?

nil slices vs non-nil slices vs empty slices in Go language


t
tgogos

As an addition to @ANisus' answer...

below is some information from the "Go in action" book, which I think is worth mentioning:

Difference between nil & empty slices

If we think of a slice like this:

[pointer] [length] [capacity]

then:

nil slice:   [nil][0][0]
empty slice: [addr][0][0] // points to an address

nil slice They’re useful when you want to represent a slice that doesn’t exist, such as when an exception occurs in a function that returns a slice. // Create a nil slice of integers. var slice []int empty slice Empty slices are useful when you want to represent an empty collection, such as when a database query returns zero results. // Use make to create an empty slice of integers. slice := make([]int, 0) // Use a slice literal to create an empty slice of integers. slice := []int{} Regardless of whether you’re using a nil slice or an empty slice, the built-in functions append, len, and cap work the same.

Go playground example:

package main

import (
    "fmt"
)

func main() {

    var nil_slice []int
    var empty_slice = []int{}

    fmt.Println(nil_slice == nil, len(nil_slice), cap(nil_slice))
    fmt.Println(empty_slice == nil, len(empty_slice), cap(empty_slice))

}

prints:

true 0 0
false 0 0

Can we get the address of empty slice in one step using make?
If we take a look at the function signature, make doesn't seem to return the address. I believe you can't do it in one step.
I
IanS

Empty slice and nil slice are initialized differently in Go:

var nilSlice []int 
emptySlice1 := make([]int, 0)
emptySlice2 := []int{}

fmt.Println(nilSlice == nil)    // true
fmt.Println(emptySlice1 == nil) // false
fmt.Println(emptySlice2 == nil) // false

As for all three slices, len and cap are 0.


make([]int, 0) is the best because Jetbrains GoLand does not complain about it being "unnecessary" as it does in the case of []int{}. This is useful in writing unit tests.
T
Tsvetelin Pantev

In addition to @ANisus' answer

When using the official Go MongoDb Driver, a nil slice will also marshal into "null" whereas an empty slice will marshal into "[]".

When using using the community supported MGO driver, both nil and empty slices will be marshalled into "[]".

Reference: https://jira.mongodb.org/browse/GODRIVER-971